Kris Faafoi is chief executive of the Insurance Council of New Zealand | Te Kāhui Inihui o Aotearoa (ICNZ). This article appeared in The Post on 29 September 2026.
Recent developments at Fire and Emergency New Zealand (FENZ) have raised serious questions around the governance, accountability and structure of an organisation Kiwis rely on every day.
Those questions must be addressed through the proper processes, without prejudging their outcome.
But they should not detract from the essential work firefighters and other frontline personnel do every day, helping people and communities in their moments of greatest need.
The Insurance Council of New Zealand (ICNZ) strongly supports a well-funded FENZ and the vital work of its people.
The current scrutiny does, however, provide an opportunity to look more broadly at whether the arrangements supporting this nationwide emergency service remain fit for purpose.
That should include how FENZ is funded.
Funding is not separate from governance. It is central to an organisation’s design, determining who pays, how costs are shared and how transparently public money is accounted for.
FENZ is funded largely through a levy collected on insurance policies.
That approach may have made sense when fire services were primarily focused on protecting insured property from fire.
It makes much less sense today.
Today, FENZ responds to road crashes, hazardous substance incidents, medical emergencies and civil defence events, as well as fires.
FENZ is a broad public emergency service that benefits every New Zealander. It does not, and should not, check whether a home, vehicle or business is insured before responding.
Yet insured households and businesses carry much of the cost.
People without relevant insurance contribute little or nothing through the levy, while some Crown-owned assets are self-insured or covered through other arrangements.
The levy system also creates inconsistencies.
Owners of similar properties can pay very different levies depending on how their insurance is structured, even though the benefit they receive from emergency services is essentially the same.
That is neither the fairest nor the most sustainable way to fund a service available to everyone.
There is another important reason to revisit the current approach. Insurance helps households, businesses and communities recover from unexpected events, but affordability is being tested by increasing weather-related losses, construction and reinsurance costs, inflation, and government charges.
Government taxes and levies account for around 40% of a typical home insurance premium, with the FENZ levy making up around 5%. Across the insurance products subject to the levy, it accounts for approximately 9% of premiums.
Every additional charge makes insurance harder for some households and businesses to maintain.
At a time when New Zealand needs to strengthen resilience and maintain broad insurance coverage, it is reasonable to ask whether insurance premiums remain the right mechanism for funding a nationwide public service.
Emergency services must still be paid for. The question is how to spread that cost more fairly.
The Government is already evaluating whether there are better ways to fund FENZ than through the current insurance levy.
ICNZ believes the simplest and fairest option would be to fund FENZ through general taxation.
Emergency services provide a public benefit to the entire country, so its funding should come from the broadest possible base.
If full Crown funding is not preferred, there are other options worthy of serious consideration.
Property-based contributions could be collected through rates or another property mechanism. Vehicle-related responses could be supported through vehicle registration, similar to the way ACC levies are collected.
These approaches would widen the funding base and bring more currently under-contributing assets into the system. They would also better reflect the reality that FENZ protects people and communities, not just insured property.
International experience shows reform is possible.
Most Australian states have moved away from insurance-based fire service levies. Comparable jurisdictions use general taxation, local government funding, property-based charges or a combination of these approaches. New South Wales, one of the few remaining Australian jurisdictions with an insurance-linked model, is also considering change.
Any reform would require careful design and consultation. Affordability, collection methods and transition arrangements would all need to be worked through. The aim should not be simply to shift costs from one group to another, but to create a broader, fairer and more transparent funding base.
Complexity, however, should not become an excuse for retaining an increasingly outdated system.
New Zealanders agree on the need for a strong, well-resourced FENZ.
The task now is to ensure its governance commands confidence and its funding is fair, sustainable and suited to the modern emergency service New Zealand relies on.
